Competing on Price: A Boutique Professional Service Firm’s Dilemma

Competing on Price: A Boutique Professional Service Firm’s Dilemma

Understanding the Low-Cost Provider Landscape

As a founder of a boutique professional service firm, you might find yourself at a crossroads, pondering if competing on price is the right strategy for your business. To navigate this critical decision, it’s essential to understand what being a low-cost provider entails and the nuances of price-based competition.

What It Means to Be a Low-Cost Provider

Being a low-cost provider is more than just slashing prices. It’s a strategic choice that involves positioning your firm as the most economical option in the market. This doesn’t necessarily mean being the cheapest, but rather offering the best value for money. For example, you might charge the same, or more, per hour but you get the work done in half the time as the competitors. To the client, you are the low-cost provider. However, internally, you manage to exceptional gross margins.

The Role of the Economizer

In this context, becoming an ‘economizer’ is key. This means not only setting competitive prices but also ensuring your operational model supports this strategy. As an economizer, your goal is to help clients save time and money, thus delivering value that goes beyond just the monetary aspect. Small service firms are well suited to play the role of economizer as they are easier to do business with, and can simplify for clients.

The Big Vs. Small Firm Conundrum

Large firms often have the upper hand in being low-cost providers due to their ability to squeeze costs out of inefficiencies at scale. They leverage volume, streamlined processes, and economies of scale to reduce costs, passing some of these savings to their clients.

For boutique firms, competing head-on with larger rivals on price can be a risky strategy. Smaller firms typically lack the scale to absorb cost reductions without impacting profitability. But does this mean you should abandon the idea of competing on price? Not necessarily.

Reengineering Service Delivery: The Smart Approach

For boutique firms, a smarter approach lies in reengineering how services are delivered. This involves innovating and finding unique ways to provide services more efficiently. By doing so, you can reduce costs while simultaneously enhancing service quality.

This approach requires a deep understanding of your clients’ needs and a willingness to challenge the status quo. It’s about being agile, adapting quickly to changes, and leveraging technology to streamline processes. For example, large firms often overengineer their service offering to justify a high price. The more complex and difficult a project the more people it requires and the longer the work will take to complete. Small service firms can show a client that this complexity is not required, that there is a simpler way to solve a problem. And, therefore, it requires fewer people and less time, thus it costs less.

Can You Compete on Price?

So, can a boutique professional service firm compete on price? Yes, but with a caveat. It’s not about being the cheapest option, but rather about providing exceptional value. Your strategy should focus on reengineering your service delivery to lower costs while maintaining, or even improving, service quality.

In Conclusion

Competing on price as a boutique firm is feasible, but it demands a strategic approach focused on operational efficiencies and innovative service delivery. Remember, in the world of professional services, value often trumps price. Your goal should be to provide unmatched service at a price point that reflects the value you offer, not just the cost to deliver it.

Are you wondering if you can win on price? Are you charging too much, or too little, for your services? If so, consider joining Collective 54. Members ask, and answer questions like this for each other, based on their first hand personal experiences. Apply here.

Ego vs Vanity: The Founder’s Dilemma That Shapes Your Destiny

Ego vs Vanity: The Founder’s Dilemma That Shapes Your Destiny

Greg Alexander in Entrepreneur’s Organization 

A healthy ego can be an entrepreneur’s best friend. But when vanity intrudes, all the puzzle pieces start to come apart. 

The terms “ego” and “vanity” tend to be misunderstood. The ego represents your sense of self. The ego is concerned about what you think of you. (That’s not a typo.) Vanity brings the outside world into the mix. When you ask, “What do other people think of me?” — that’s your vanity talking. 

It’s perfectly reasonable for entrepreneurs to lead with ego. The ego sets up your expectations for yourself, after all. When you’re pursuing dreams and self-actualization, you’re leveraging your ego. However, when you’re only motivated by inauthentic external goals like prestige, status and influence, your attention is diverted from what really matters. 

I once worked with a founder who became distracted by vanity. He was a member of our organization and involved in the sales training industry. Specifically, he focused on social selling, a niche that relies on social media platforms to reach prospects and win new sales. 

When LinkedIn first hit the scene, he became somewhat of a celebrity and garnered thousands of followers. His posts were liked, shared and commented on. He was popular, as quantified by LinkedIn, and the so-called “vanity metrics” gave him a false sense of accomplishment. Why false? Though he appeared successful to everyone else, a deep dive into his profit and loss sheet revealed he was barely making ends meet. 

Did he become discouraged when he realized his vanity had let him down? Of course. Yet, this entrepreneur was one of those rare people who could face his failings. He said to himself, “I’m not happy. I’m working very hard, but I’m not making real money. Who cares if the mob thinks I’m cool? I need to build a real business and support my family.” Essentially, his ego rescued him — and he’s now more centered and intentional with his time. 

Harnessing Your Ego: Living an Authentic Life in an Inauthentic World 

If you find it challenging to keep your vanity at bay, you’re not alone. We live in a world where inauthenticity reigns. This doesn’t mean you can’t strengthen your ego, though. I recommend three steps to harness your ego power and let go of your vanity. 

    1. See yourself as a missionary and not a mercenary. When you create and follow a personal mission, you’re building upon your ego in a fruitful way. My mission statement is “to live a fulfilling life by taking risks and competing for extraordinary accomplishments.” My mission statement is entirely driven by me, not by anyone else. Only I can define what it means to be fulfilled. The statement includes no external vanity measures such as dollar amount, job title, or client list. 
    2. Design a personal vision to lay atop your mission statement. Once again, I’ll share my vision statement: “To be healthy and wealthy. Health is defined as a tough mind, deep soul, and fit body. Wealth is defined as an abundance of time and relationships.” The vision guides how I set up my schedule. I devote hours, days, weeks, months, and years to educating my mind, enriching my soul, eating well, exercising, and sleeping. No one else knows or sees my progress. It’s completely invisible to them and can only be analyzed and meaningful to me (courtesy of my ego). 
    3. Establish your core values. Values define how you will behave and hold yourself accountable. One of my eight core values is to be a loyal community member, helping others get the most out of their lives. This value led me to launch a community for professional service firm founders. Without the ego-driven personal values I live by, my venture wouldn’t exist. 

Too many entrepreneurs feed their vanity and wind up holding themselves accountable to everyone else. Don’t let your vanity get in the way of your ego. Your ego will make you successful — and keep you that way. 

Contributed to EO by Greg Alexander, the founder of Collective 54, the first mastermind community dedicated to helping professional services firms grow, scale and exit. Prior to founding Collective 54, Greg started, scaled and sold a consulting firm for nine figures. In addition, he is the author of the best-selling book, “The Boutique: How To Start, Scale, And Sell A Professional Service Firm,” and hosts the number one podcast of the same name. Greg received his undergraduate degree from the University of Massachusetts and his MBA from Georgia Tech.

For more insights and inspiration from today’s leading entrepreneurs, check out EO on Inc. and more articles from the EO blog

How to Align Sales Compensation with Your Firm’s Ideal Client Profile

How to Align Sales Compensation with Your Firm’s Ideal Client Profile

Understanding Good, Neutral, and Bad Revenue in Professional Service Firms

As the founder of a boutique professional service firm, you understand the importance of growth. But not all revenue is equal. In our quest for growth, it’s crucial to distinguish between good, neutral, and bad revenue – and align our sales compensation accordingly. This approach not only accelerates growth but ensures it’s sustainable and aligned with our core values and business goals.

Good Revenue: The Lifeblood of Your Firm

Good revenue is the kind that comes from clients who fit your firm’s Ideal Client Profile (ICP). These clients are not just profitable; they resonate with your firm’s expertise and values. They are the clients who appreciate your unique offerings and are willing to pay a premium for them. This type of revenue contributes to the long-term health and growth of your firm.

Neutral Revenue: The Opportunistic Capital

Neutral revenue comes from clients who don’t perfectly fit your ICP but still bring in working capital. This revenue is opportunistic and can support your firm during growth phases. However, it’s important not to lose focus on your ICP while dealing with such clients.

Bad Revenue: The Hidden Cost

Bad revenue, the most insidious of all, comes from clients who fall far outside your ICP. This type of revenue can be detrimental as it diverts your firm’s resources, focus, and energy from more aligned opportunities. It can lead to mission drift, employee dissatisfaction, and even damage your brand.

Aligning Sales Compensation

Now, let’s talk sales compensation design. Your sales team is the frontline in attracting and securing revenue. Their compensation should be strategically aligned with the kind of revenue they bring in.

    1. Rewarding Good Revenue

Salespeople should be incentivized to pursue and close deals with ICP-aligned clients. Consider paying a premium for good revenue. This can be in the form of higher commissions, bonuses, or SPIFFS. This not only motivates your team to focus on high-quality leads but also aligns their efforts with the firm’s strategic objectives.

    1. Neutral Revenue Compensation

For neutral revenue, stick to the standard rate of compensation. This acknowledges the effort put in by the sales team while subtly nudging them towards more ICP-aligned prospects.

    1. Discouraging Bad Revenue

Do not compensate sales for bad revenue. This might sound harsh, but it sends a clear message about the firm’s priorities. It’s crucial to communicate why certain clients are considered ‘bad’ for the business so your sales team understands the rationale behind this policy.

Conclusion

In a boutique professional service firm, growth is not just about increasing numbers; it’s about growing right. By aligning your sales compensation with your firm’s ideal client profile, you not only incentivize your team to bring in the most beneficial clients but also ensure that your firm stays true to its vision and values.

Remember, the goal is sustainable growth, and that comes from understanding and valuing the quality of revenue, not just the quantity.

Ideal client profiles and sales compensation are but only two topics discussed by members of Collective. If you think you might want to learn from your peers, consider joining Collective 54. You can apply here.

Why Employee Turnover Can Be a Gift for Boutique Professional Service Firms

Why Employee Turnover Can Be a Gift for Boutique Professional Service Firms

In the ever-evolving landscape of boutique professional service firms, the notion of employee turnover often comes shrouded in negative connotations. However, as a founder, it’s crucial to adopt a perspective that sees turnover not just as an inevitable part of the business cycle, but as a potential catalyst for growth and rejuvenation. This blog post explores why embracing employee turnover can be a strategic move for your firm.

The Refreshing Wave of New Perspectives

Embracing Change

Every exit of an employee opens a door to new perspectives. Fresh talent brings with it updated skills, innovative ideas, and diverse experiences that can inject new life into stagnant processes. In the boutique professional service industry, where adaptability and innovation are key, this influx of fresh blood can be the difference between remaining relevant or becoming obsolete.

An Example: Reinvigorating Strategy

Consider a boutique consulting firm that recently experienced a wave of turnover. The new hires brought in a fresh set of eyes and proposed cutting-edge solutions that hadn’t been considered previously, leading to a significant increase in client satisfaction and business growth.

The Hidden Cost of Complacency

Long Tenure vs. Stagnation

While long-tenured employees are often seen as the backbone of a firm, there’s a hidden danger in complacency. Founders need to be vigilant about employees who might be ‘phoning it in’, lacking the drive and hunger that’s essential in a dynamic professional environment. Their disengagement can be more detrimental than the disruption caused by employee turnover. And, at times, work from home can mean working part time, especially for long tenured employees who feel entitled.

An Example: The Complacent Veteran

Imagine a senior employee who hasn’t updated their skills or brought any innovative ideas to the table in years. Their comfort with the status quo could subtly impede the firm’s ability to grow and scale.

The Opportunity for Cultural Rejuvenation

Building a Dynamic Culture

Turnover offers a unique opportunity to reassess and realign your firm’s culture. It allows for a cultural reset where new values and behaviors that align with the firm’s vision can be instilled. Fresh hires can act as catalysts, bringing energy and enthusiasm that reinvigorates the entire team. This is especially true for older lifestyle firms who have recently decided to become more than a lifestyle firm. Turning over legacy employees in the lifestyle firm is, at times, a requirement.

An Example: The Fresh Culture Effect

A boutique firm that embraced turnover saw a marked improvement in its work culture. New employees introduced more collaborative and innovative work practices, which were quickly adopted by the existing team, leading to enhanced team dynamics and productivity.

Strategic Talent Management

Quality over Longevity

In the world of professional services, the quality of your team is your biggest asset. It’s crucial to focus on attracting and retaining talent that is not only skilled but also hungry for success. Employee turnover, in this regard, can be an effective filter, ensuring that your team remains high-caliber and dedicated. This is why the firms that have reached scale have adopted the up-or-out pyramid organizational structure. In this model, employees need to develop and move up or get out of the way for the next generation.

An Example: The Right Fit

A recent example from a boutique financial advisory firm demonstrates this. They used turnover as an opportunity to realign their talent with their strategic goals, leading to better client relationships and improved financial performance. This fractional CFO firm decided they were going up market, serving middle market, private equity backed software firms. This required them to leave their core market, the small business owner. And, as you can imagine, new talent was required.

Reinforcing the Growth Mindset

Embracing a Learning Environment

Turnover can foster a culture of continuous learning and improvement. New employees often seek growth and development, which can inspire the entire team to adopt a growth mindset. This approach is invaluable in the professional services sector, where staying ahead of industry trends is crucial.

An Example: Growth Through Diversity

A boutique marketing firm capitalized on turnover by hiring individuals from diverse professional backgrounds instead of industry retreads, leading to innovative marketing strategies that significantly boosted their client engagement.

Conclusion
Employee turnover in boutique professional service firms should not be viewed through a lens of loss but as an opportunity for growth, innovation, and cultural rejuvenation. While the departure of employees can be challenging, it opens up avenues for fresh talent and ideas that can drive your firm forward.

Call to Action
If you’re a founder looking to strategically navigate the complexities of running a boutique professional service firm, consider joining Collective 54. Our community offers a wealth of knowledge, resources, and a network of like-minded professionals who can help you turn challenges like employee turnover into opportunities for growth. Apply for membership today and start transforming the way you see your business and its team.

The AI Revolution: An Urgent Wake-Up Call for Boutique Professional Service Firms

The AI Revolution: An Urgent Wake-Up Call for Boutique Professional Service Firms

The Inevitable March of AI: Adapt or Perish

Dear Founders of Boutique Professional Service Firms,

In this rapidly evolving era of artificial intelligence (AI), I want to extend a stark, yet vital message: Adapt to AI, or risk obsolescence. This isn’t fearmongering; it’s a reality check. As leaders in consulting, marketing, IT services, design, fractional executive roles, and other expert driven segments, the time to act is now. AI isn’t just changing the game; it’s rewriting the rules entirely.

Understanding the AI Imperative

Yes/No Checklist: Assessing Your AI Readiness                               

    • Are you up to date with how AI can/will replace traditional jobs in professional services, i.e., associates, analysts, engagement managers, etc.?
    • Do you understand the profit expansion opportunity that this presents to you, the owner?
    • Have you started your firm on the steep AI learning curve yet?
    • Do you understand the imminent risks of ignoring AI in your industry?

If you answered ‘No’ to any of these questions, you’re already trailing behind. Giddy up!

Read on.

Consulting Firms: AI as a Competitive Edge

For boutique consulting firms, AI isn’t just a tool; it’s a game-changer. Imagine leveraging AI for deep data analysis, offering insights far beyond human capabilities. This isn’t a future scenario; it’s happening now. Consulting firms will dramatically expand in scale and scope beginning in 2024. Scale has been constrained, historically, by labor. Employees could only produce so much. AI removes this constraint for the machine has infinite capacity, which means consulting firms can serve far more clients at any given time. Scope has also been constrained, historically, by labor. Employees could only master so many areas of expertise. AI removes this constraint for the machine has access to the world’s expertise and can process it in a nanosecond. This means firms can offer more services than ever to an expanding client roster.

Case Study: A small market research firm specializing in unified communications leveraged AI to acquire a new client. They recently beat a larger competitor for a lucrative custom research project because they offered a richer offering at a more attractive price point. How? The legacy firm used expensive subject matter experts to perform slow and inefficient tasks, i.e., surveys and interviews, to produce the deliverable. The boutique firm used large language models, unique data sets sitting in legacy systems of the client, and decision tree logic to produce the deliverable.

Marketing Agencies: AI-Driven Personalization

In marketing, AI is revolutionizing how we understand consumer behavior. AI-driven analytics can predict customer preferences, enabling hyper-personalized campaigns that resonate on a deeper level, nudging prospects to take the desired action.

Case Study: A boutique marketing agency implemented AI to help a SaaS company predict and prevent churn. The agency used Facebook’s “loyalty prediction tool” which curated thousands of data points across its user base to serve up retention offers to the SaaS companies user base who had been labeled at risk. The campaign saved dozens of users from churning, producing a 6x return on the campaign budget.

IT Service Firms: Automating for Efficiency

IT service firms stand at the forefront of the AI revolution. Automation of routine tasks frees up valuable resources. Most MSPs, managed service providers, offer a limited number of services to their clients. This is because of the talent shortage currently present in key technical areas. The MSP’s scale is constrained by its ability to recruit, hire, onboard, make productive and retain technical talent. AI removes this constraint. The “machine” works 24/7/365, never quits, and learns new skills at PhD level.

Case Study: An IT firm specializing in email deliverability used AI to stand up new domains, email addresses, and thousands of emails each with fresh copy that its client used in its outbound marketing activities. Their client went from very low email deliverability to almost perfect email deliverability. And, given this was the client’s primary marketing channel, the marketing funnel was filled with fresh prospects interested in the clients’ products and services. The MSP converted the client from a month-to-month transactional relationship to a multi-year outsourcing agreement.

Fractional CFO Firms: Financial Analysis

In the realm of fractional CFO services, AI’s ability to perform for clients is remarkable. For example, AI can forecast revenues and expenses with a precision that human analysis can’t match, given its ability to digest enormous amounts of data. The “machine” performs the strategic work of a CFO, the project work of a controller, the tax work of an accountant, and the bookkeeping tasks of a bookkeeper. Four roles combined into one. Firms in the fractional finance vertical are about to have their moment. Their value proposition just went up exponentially.

Case Study: A fractional CFO firm was able to move up market, from serving small business owners, to serving midmarket companies. Traditionally, midmarket companies ($100 million -$1 billion) felt that outsourcing the finance function was inappropriate. The belief there was too much work, too much risk, and that quality would suffer. This firm, truly tech enabled, offer the client a no risk and free proof of concept for their smallest business unit. The work was better than the in-house staff. For example, they closed the month in one day versus one week. And the cost was 1/10th of the in-house staff. As of this publication date, the firm was in the process of taking over the entire finance function. This client is now the top revenue producer for the boutique service firm.

The Emotional Imperative: Fear of Falling Behind

Let me be blunt: fear in this context is rational. It’s the fear of being left in the dust by competitors who embraced AI while you hesitated. It’s the fear of watching your hard-earned business become irrelevant because you clung to outdated practices. You are human and are burdened with the flight or fight DNA. Acknowledge your fear and deal with it. Give yourself permission to have an “oh shit” moment. However, get over it, and in a hurry. This is here. You must reinvent your firm. I hope this article serves as the moment you say to yourself “okay I am doing this. One foot in front of the other.”

Conclusion: A Call to Courageous Action

To all founders of boutique professional service firms, this is your wake-up call. The AI revolution is here, and it’s relentless. Ignoring it isn’t just imprudent; it’s a direct path to professional extinction. Embrace AI, reinvent your processes, and prepare to lead in a new, AI-driven world.

It’s not just about survival; it’s about seizing the opportunity to redefine your industry and your future. Fear can be a powerful motivator, but let it be the kind that propels you forward, not one that paralyzes you into inaction.

Do you want help? Join a mastermind community and get access to how your peers are dealing with the AI imperative. Apply here.

The Seven Blind Spots of Boutique Professional Service Firm Founders

The Seven Blind Spots of Boutique Professional Service Firm Founders

In the world of boutique professional service firms, the role of the founder is pivotal. However, even the most astute founders are susceptible to certain blind spots that can hinder their firm’s growth and success. Here, we discuss the seven critical blind spots that founders often overlook, their implications, and how addressing these can lead to a more prosperous future for their firms.

    1. Filtering: The Distorted Lens

Filtering refers to how founders process information when making decisions. In small service firms, there’s a tendency to distort facts, often unconsciously. This selective absorption of information leads to decisions based on partial data, overlooking crucial aspects that might be critical for the firm’s wellbeing. For example, making a key hiring decision because the recruit has a similar background to yours.

    1. Relying on Hunches: The Trap of Self-Fulfilling Prophecies

Many founders fill gaps in information with their own assumptions or hunches. While intuition can be a powerful tool, over-reliance on it can lead founders into the trap of self-fulfilling prophecies. These hunches, unchecked by factual data, can steer the firm in a direction based more on belief than reality. For example, investing in launching a new service offering without validating the market will buy it.

    1. Soothsaying: The Arrogance of Prediction

Soothsaying involves attempting to predict the future with little concrete evidence. This blind spot is particularly dangerous as it can lead founders to commit resources to strategies based on shaky forecasts, often fueled by arrogance rather than practical analysis. For example, hiring more capacity based on a rosy sales forecast.

    1. Retrospection: The Fictionalized Past

Founders often use selective memory to guide future decisions, converting the actual past into a more palatable, often fictionalized version. This retrospection can lead to repeated mistakes or missed opportunities, as the true lessons from the past are obscured. For example, making yourself feel better about a lost client by telling yourself “They just don’t get it.”

    1. Categorizing: The Shortcut to Decision Making

In the time-starved world of boutique service firms, founders often resort to categorizing – labeling and judging situations quickly to save time. While this can be efficient, it often leads to poor snap judgments and oversimplifications of complex situations. For example, dismissing a best practice at first glance.

    1. Emotions: The Clouding of Judgement

Emotions play a significant role in decision-making, but they can also cloud judgment, blocking out logic. Founders, driven by passion, can sometimes let their emotions override rational decision-making, leading to choices that aren’t in the best interest of their firm. For example, carrying a bloated payroll because laying employees off is painful.

    1. Magnifications: The Extremes of Perception

Magnification involves blowing things out of proportion, making the highs too high and the lows too low. This distortion can lead to overreactions, either overly optimistic or pessimistic, which can destabilize the firm’s strategic direction. For example, when your firm hits a tough patch, and you implement draconian cost cutting because you think the sky is falling.

Conclusion: Overcoming Blind Spots for Success

For boutique professional service firms to grow, scale, and reach a successful exit, they require leadership from a capable founder. A founder suffering from these seven blind spots is not operating at full capacity. Recognizing and addressing these blind spots is essential. Founders who identify with one or more of these pitfalls should invest in personal development efforts to mitigate their effects. This is not just about individual improvement but about ensuring the health and future success of the firm. Remember, overcoming these blind spots is not just a personal victory; it’s a triumph for the entire firm.

A membership in a peer group is an effective way to address these blind spots. And Collective 54 might be the right group for you to join. If you are interested, apply here.

Why I Chose to Implement ESOP at Integral: Beyond the Balance Sheet

Why I Chose to Implement ESOP at Integral: Beyond the Balance Sheet

We are pleased to present a unique feature on our blog today. The following post comes courtesy of a guest contributor, Collective 54 member Ashok Sivanand, CEO @ IntegralWe are honored to share his knowledge and viewpoints with our readers. Enjoy this unique piece that broadens the horizons of our usual content.

During my time at Shoplogix and Pivotal Labs, I experienced the transformative power of Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOP). While the outcomes for me were moderate at-best, (think downpayment on a house), I was fortunate to have experienced this first-hand on my journey to founding Integral.

Witnessing how ESOP reshaped the workplace was enlightening – it felt more than business strategy. It was a catalyst for a more engaged and vibrant company culture. Compared to my time at larger enterprises, I clearly felt and experienced increased employee commitment, a surge in tenacity, and a strong sense of belonging among employees. This wasn’t just about numbers; it was about nurturing a workplace where everyone feels invested and accountable to our collective success.

My close interactions with the founders offered me a unique perspective on the intrinsic value of ESOPs and how they help bridge the typical divide between shareholder and employee. ESOPs create a shared sense of purpose and success, transforming every team member into a stakeholder in our collective journey.

The Viability of ESOP in Professional Services

Implementing ESOP in a professional services setup isn’t always a straightforward path. Similar to how Collective 54 has a pro-serve specific model to EOS (Entrepreneurial Operating System), ESOP demands tailoring the popular models catered to product companies to fit our industry dimensions

Considerations at the Forefront

Here are some of the top considerations we had to confirm in order to confidently implement our program.

    • Intent of Business: Decide early whether you’re running a lifestyle business or growing a scaled business. It’s my opinion that an ESOP makes a lot more sense for the latter.
    • Structural Choices: While it’s more straightforward to implement the program for a C-Corp, there are various approaches like phantom stock that can help achieve the same goals for an LLC.
    • Vesting Strategies: Consider whether vesting happens based on time (eg. 4 years), performance, or some combination. Time-based vests are a lot simpler to implement and will likely work for most cases.
    • Ownership Percentages: Decide early what percentage of the business you want to allocate to the stock option pool. Since you can always allocate more shares in the future, i’d recommend starting small. We started with 15% with the intent of adding another 15% as we grow.
    • Compensation Balance: Generally, stock options allocations follow similar proportions as salary allocations. The % of upside an employee might receive from the equity versus their salary increases as the employee is more senior.
    • Stage of the Firm: In the earlier days, when cash was tight and we couldn’t afford to pay market salaries, we allocated higher values of stock options. As we grew, we adjusted to market compensation and reduced the stock option allocation per employee.
    • Managing Exits: Plan for scenarios like key employees leaving and be transparent about it. I have witnessed peers end up in wasteful legal battles with senior executives leaving and trying to take them off the cap table.
    • Dividends for Alumni: If you choose to pay out dividends, you’ll have to decide early whether alumni shareholders get paid those dividends. Like the point above, this can seem difficult, especially if the alumni left on bad terms. My advice is to remind you that you set out to build something great. Channel that emotional energy toward solving meaningful problems and serving more people and chalk these payments up to “dumb taxes” as the Collective 54 members call it.

Implementing ESOP: Legal and Practical Learnings

    • Choosing the Right Law Firm: It’s crucial to work with a firm that has experience with this. My initial struggle with a non-specialized firm led to high costs and no results, whereas a specialized firm in Palo Alto was more efficient and cost-effective.The initial cost was $3,500 with the right firm.
    • Options Galore: There’s a variety to choose from, like ISO/NSO. At the bottom of this post, I have attached a table prepared by my legal firm in 2017. I would advice legal and tax consult to confirm this information is still relevant before taking action. Deciding between options is more about aligning with your company’s values and principles than just logic or math.

Operationalizing the ESOP Program

    • Educating Employees: We observed a trend where many colleagues either undervalued or overvalued their stock options. Addressing this through regular education sessions and transparent communication about valuations has been key.
    • Encouraging Voluntary Participation: We’ve been cautious not to sway employees towards participating or create a divide between those who exercise their options and those who don’t. It’s tempting to use future valuations as a significant part of compensation, but this should be approached carefully based on the factors mentioned above.
    • Attracting Talent: Interestingly, some colleagues were drawn to our firm because of the stock option program, resonating with their own values and aspirations to be part of the firm’s growth trajectory. They chose us over competing offers and marginally higher compensation for the value alignment.
    • Maintaining Transparency and Fairness: We emphasize transparency in our operations but also respect privacy by keeping shareholder identities confidential and ensuring equitable treatment.
    • Tools for Efficient Management: I highly recommend software tools like Capshare or Carta for managing ESOP programs and your annual valuations (409A). These tools offer efficiency and clarity in administration.

Implementing an Employee Stock Ownership Plan in a professional services firm is more than just a strategic decision; it’s a transformative journey towards collective growth and success. ESOPs offer a unique opportunity to align the interests of your employees with those of the company, creating a powerful sense of ownership and shared destiny. This alignment not only enhances engagement and commitment but also drives innovation and performance, as every team member becomes an integral part of the firm’s success story. As you grow and evolve your firm, consider the profound impact that an ESOP can have. It’s not just about sharing financial success; it’s about fostering a culture of unity, motivation, and collective achievement. Embrace this opportunity to not only grow your business but to also enrich the lives of those who contribute to its growth. Let the journey of ESOP be your firm’s stepping stone to new heights of success and fulfillment.

 CorporationCorporationLLCLLCCorporation/LLC
Incentive AwardIncentive Stock Option (ISO) (early exercisable) (employees only)Non-qualified Stock Option (NSO) (early exercisable)Option to purchase common LLC Unit (early exercisable)Profits InterestCash Incentive Program
MechanismEmployee is granted an option to purchase shares of the Company’s common stock in the future, exercisable immediately but subject to vesting based on continued service to the Company.Person is granted an option to purchase shares of the Company’s common stock in the future, exercisable immediately but subject to vesting based on continued service to the CompanyPerson is granted an option to purchase units of the Company’s common equity in the future, exercisable immediately but subject to vesting based on continued service to the Company.Employee is granted an interest in the Company’s future profits and losses, which may or may not be distributed to employee depending upon operating income and tax distributions. May be subject to vesting.Program allows for grant of specified number of units, and each participant is granted a number of units, which may or may not be subject to vesting.  Payment on units made on change in control only.
DocumentationStock Option Plan, Notice of Grant, Option Agreement and Exercise Agreement.Stock Option Plan, Notice of Grant, Option Agreement and Exercise Agreement.Equity Option Plan, Notice of Grant, Option Agreement, Exercise Agreement, Operating AgreementEquity Incentive Plan, Profits Interest Agreement, Operating AgreementCash Incentive Program and Award Agreement
Exercise Price> FMV at grant> FMV at grant> FMV at grantN/AN/A
Individual’s Tax Treatment

Taxed only on sale of shares acquired upon exercise of option. If holding period is met, difference between sale price and exercise price is taxed at long-term capital gain rates.

Holding period = 1 year from exercise & 2 years from date of grant

*Spread at exercise may be included in taxable income for purposes of determining AMT.

Taxed at exercise at ordinary income rates on difference between exercise price and FMV on exercise date assuming 83(b) election is made. Additional tax upon sale at capital gain rates on difference between FMV on exercise date and sale price.Taxed at ordinary income rates when units are issued upon exercise on difference between exercise price and FMV on exercise date. Taxed on date of sale at capital gain rates on difference between FMV on exercise date and sale price.Taxed annually when profits/income is allocated to profits interest holders.  Allocation of profits to profits interest holders may occur only if certain thresholds are met.Taxed only upon payment in connection with a Change in Control.  Taxed at ordinary income tax rates when cash is received.
Treatment upon Change in ControlUnexercised awards (or exercised but unvested awards) will accelerate immediately prior to CIC unless otherwise assumed or substituted by acquirer. Holders of vested shares will receive same consideration if, when and as other stockholders are paid.Unexercised awards (or exercised but unvested awards) will accelerate immediately prior to CIC unless otherwise assumed or substituted by acquirer. Holders of vested shares will receive same consideration if, when and as other stockholders are paidUnexercised awards (or exercised but unvested awards) will accelerate immediately prior to CIC unless otherwise assumed or substituted by acquirer. Holders of vested units will receive same consideration if, when and as other stockholders are paidPaid out in accordance with terms of Operating Agreement (generally will convert into right to receive a cash payment at closing, subject to the threshold and any senior equity rights.Each unit represents the right to receive a cash amount equal to X% of the consideration paid to the Company’s owners in connection with a Change in Control, if, when and as paid to the stockholders. Program is treated as a liability that is paid out before the stockholders receive consideration for their equity.
Treatment upon IPOFull stockholder rights upon exercise of option. (Vested shares are freely tradeable.)Full stockholder rights upon exercise of option. (Vested shares are freely tradeable.)N/A (unlikely that entity would go public as LLC)N/A (unlikely that entity would go public as LLC)No payment is made without a change in control.
Treatment as Stockholder/ MemberFull stockholder rights upon exercise of option; provided that unvested equity can’t be transferred.Full stockholder rights upon exercise of option; provided that unvested equity can’t be transferred.Full member rights upon exercise of option; provided that unvested equity can’t be transferred. Eligible for tax distributions.Full member upon grant of profits interest, regardless of vesting (provided that unvested equity can’t be transferred). Eligible for tax distributions.No
Treatment as EmployeeYesYesPrior to exercise, yes. Following exercise, treated as partner, and the employee-partner will be responsible for paying the employer portion of his/her own employment taxes (FICA, Medicaid, etc.). Any benefits paid for by the company (e.g., medical benefits) cannot be provided on a tax-free basis.Immediately after grant, treated as partner and the employee-partner will be responsible for paying the employer portion of his/her own employment taxes (FICA, Medicaid, etc.). Any benefits paid for by the company (e.g., medical benefits) cannot be provided on a tax-free basis.Yes
Tax ReportingForm 3921 regarding exercise of option must be distributed by company to employee in the year following year of exercise. If option is exercised for unvested shares, Section 83(b) election must be filed by employee with IRS within 30 days of exercise.If option is exercised for unvested shares, Section 83(b) election must be filed by employee with IRS within 30 days of exercise.  Income at exercise reported by company on W-2/1099.After exercise of option, Form K-1 must be distributed annually to partner detailing partner’s shares of profits and losses for each fiscal year. If option is exercised for unvested Units, protective Section 83(b) election should be filed by employee with IRS within 30 days of exercise.Form K-1 must be distributed annually to partner detailing partner’s shares of profits and losses for each fiscal yearForm W-2 will report income earned in transaction as compensation.
Effect on Entity Tax TreatmentNo effect on entity tax treatment.No effect on entity tax treatment.Prior to exercise of first option or sale of equity to another third party, entity is treated as sole proprietorship.  Once first option is exercised or equity is sold to a third party, entity is treated as partnership. A new tax ID may be required. Partnership tax returns are then required.Prior to first grant, entity is treated as sole proprietorship.  Following first grant of a profits interest, entity is treated as partnership. A new tax ID may be required. Partnership tax returns are then required.No effect on entity tax treatment.

Understanding the Use of Debt in Boutique Professional Service Firms

Understanding the Use of Debt in Boutique Professional Service Firms

As the founder of a boutique professional service firm, one of the essential yet challenging aspects of business management is navigating the financial landscape. The question of funding and cash flow is crucial. Why might a founder consider taking out a loan? The answers are multifaceted.

For starters, external funding, especially in the early stages of a firm, can be the lifeline that ensures smooth operations, facilitates growth, and bridges the cash-flow gaps. While there are various sources of funding, loans often emerge as a preferable choice. But who might a founder borrow from? Traditional banks, credit unions, online lenders, and sometimes even professional acquaintances can offer loans, depending on the founder’s network and firm’s credentials.

Interestingly, debt financing (taking loans) often holds an edge over equity financing (giving away company shares). The reason is control. With debt, you remain the primary decision-maker, not having to dilute ownership or accommodate the interests of external shareholders. However, borrowing comes in various flavors, each tailored to specific needs.

    1. Term Loans Term loans are fundamental in the lending world. These are typically loans of a specific amount for a specific purpose. The funds can come as lump sums or in installments. Repayment generally commences from the inception of the loan and can be structured over various tenures, either being fully paid off on the maturity date or through an amortized schedule.

When is it best to use? Imagine you’re expanding your firm’s services and require new talent. A term loan would be ideal, offering you the required large sum upfront, allowing for the acquisition of the new talent.

When should it be avoided? If the firm’s cash flow is inconsistent, repaying a term loan might become a burden. In such cases, a flexible repayment structure might be more suitable.

    1. Revolving Loans Often synonymous with a line of credit, revolving loans grant founders’ access to funds up to a set limit. The magic lies in the flexibility—borrow only what’s needed and repay, usually with interest on the drawn amount.

When is it best to use? Let’s say your firm is waiting on payments from big clients, but you have immediate operational costs. A revolving loan offers the liquidity to manage such working capital requirements without borrowing a massive lump sum.

When should it be avoided? If not managed judiciously, a revolving loan can lead to perpetual debt, with the founder perpetually drawing and repaying, leading to hefty interest payments over time.

    1. Secured Loans These loans require collateral, i.e., an asset (like property or accounts receivable) that the lender can seize if repayment falters.

When is it best to use? Suppose you’re investing in cutting-edge software or technology for your firm. Given the substantial cost, a lender might seek assurance in the form of collateral. With a secured loan, you could potentially get lower interest rates due to the reduced risk for the lender.

When should it be avoided? If the risk of non-repayment is high or if the asset is indispensable to firm operations. The danger of losing the collateral can be detrimental to the firm’s functioning.

In conclusion, while loans can be a lifesaver, they come with their own set of risks. Debt is a double-edged sword—it can bolster growth but can also lead to financial distress if not managed prudently. The key lies in understanding the firm’s needs and aligning them with the right type of loan. As founders, we must recognize that every type of debt has its pitfalls, which become exacerbated when the wrong loan is opted for in an unsuitable scenario. Making informed, strategic financial decisions is vital to ensuring the firm’s sustainability and growth.

The Essential Insurance Needs of Small Service Firms

The Essential Insurance Needs of Small Service Firms

It’s an often-observed reality: many boutique professional service firms operate without sufficient insurance coverage, unwittingly exposing themselves to considerable risk. As the founder of such a firm, I know firsthand the challenges and distractions that come with managing a business. However, ensuring your enterprise is properly insured is not a luxury, it’s a necessity.

The good news? Many of these risks can be mitigated without a significant outlay, ensuring both peace of mind and long-term financial stability. Here, I’ll outline six crucial insurance types that all boutique professional service firms should seriously consider:

    1. General Liability Insurance
    • What is it? This is a broad type of insurance that covers potential claims from accidents, injuries, or negligence that might occur due to your business operations.
    • Why is it needed? Even if you deem your services as ‘low-risk’, accidents can happen. Whether it’s a client tripping over a cable in your office or damage caused by your service, the costs can be hefty.
    • Risk of not having it: Without this coverage, a single lawsuit or claim could financially devastate your firm.
    1. Errors and Omissions (E&O) Insurance
    • What is it? E&O insurance (often called “professional liability insurance”) protects against claims of inadequate work or negligent actions.
    • Why is it needed? Professionals, regardless of their field, are human and can make mistakes. If an error or oversight on your part leads to client financial loss, this insurance can cover the damages.
    • Risk of not having it: A mistake, whether real or perceived by a client, without coverage could result in huge out-of-pocket legal fees and compensation.
    1. Business Interruption Insurance
    • What is it? This insurance compensates for lost income and operational expenses if your business is unable to function due to a disaster or unforeseen event.
    • Why is it needed? Events like fires, floods, or even global pandemics can halt operations. This insurance ensures that even during halts, rents, salaries, and other bills are paid.
    • Risk of not having it: Without this, a temporary business halt could become a permanent shutdown.
    1. Key Person Life and Disability Insurance
    • What is it? A policy that protects the business if a key employee (often the owner or crucial executive) dies or becomes disabled.
    • Why is it needed? In boutique firms, operations often rely heavily on a few key individuals. Their sudden absence can gravely affect business performance.
    • Risk of not having it: Loss of a key person without this insurance can lead to significant business interruptions, loss of clients, or even business closure.
    1. Insurance to Fund Share Repurchase upon Death or Disability
    • What is it? An agreement that if a business partner dies or becomes incapacitated, the remaining partners can buy out the affected partner’s share, often with the payout from a life insurance policy.
    • Why is it needed? It ensures smooth transition and operations even after a partner’s sudden exit.
    • Risk of not having it: Without this arrangement, surviving owners might struggle to gain control of the departed’s share, leading to business disputes or operational difficulties.
    1. Cyber Liability Insurance
    • What is it? Insurance that covers businesses in the event of cyber breaches or attacks.
    • Why is it needed? The digital age, while bringing efficiency, also brings cyber threats. Data breaches can result in legal fees, notification costs, and damage to reputation.
    • Risk of not having it: A cyber-attack without this insurance can cause irreparable financial and reputational harm.

In summary, the world of professional service is intricate and full of nuances, making risk management through proper insurance imperative. It’s about more than just safeguarding against potential threats; it’s about fortifying your firm’s foundation, ensuring longevity, and offering both your team and your clients the assurance that you’re a stable and trustworthy entity. Don’t let oversight or attempts to cut costs today jeopardize your firm’s future.

If you find this article helpful, come join us at Collective 54. Apply here.

How to Win in a Fragmented Market

How to Win in a Fragmented Market

Greg Alexander in American Express 

Understanding and appreciating what makes fragmented markets distinctive is important. When you understand them better – especially those in the professional services field – you can adjust your operations to consistently improve your market share and margins.

What is a fragmented market? From a broad brushstroke perspective, a fragmented market is essentially a large market with plenty of providers. No single firm effectively dominates the market, though. Instead, there is an even spread of companies serving all customers.

A prime instance of a fragmented market is the fast food sector, with its almost endless supply of eateries to choose from. The opportunities to serve are spread out among countless organizations rather than concentrated among just a few key players.

Fragmented markets are so familiar that we tend to take them for granted. Yet, understanding and appreciating what makes fragmented markets distinctive is important. When you understand them better – especially those in the professional services field – you can adjust your operations to consistently improve your market share and margins.

Why Does Market Fragmentation Occur?

Understandably, figuring out how to grow or scale your professional services business in a fragmented market can seem hard. After all, you can’t just go with the typical approach, which involves consolidating the market via acquisitions and roll-ups. This won’t work because of several realities.

The first reality that gets in the way of consolidation is that clients can expect a high degree of personalization from the firms they choose. Consequently, it can be difficult to standardize, develop a routine, and reduce labor. Economies of scale don’t tend to dovetail with customization.

Another snag relates to selling. Professional service firms’ sales tend to be made using relationships and referrals. Here’s why that’s a concern: consolidating a market by rolling up disparate firms often leads to centralized sales efforts and a lowered focus on relationships. Therefore, revenue growth historically attached to relationship selling may begin to suffer.

Along those same lines, professional service firms hired by clients that want help solving new problems with innovative approaches can feel stifled after a merger or acquisition. Rather than being able to adjust, flex, and create, they become bogged down by consolidation-related policies and procedures. Unsurprisingly, this can stifle client responsiveness and hurt growth.

Finally, it’s worth mentioning that many firms are run by individuals who see them as lifestyle businesses. These owner-operators may not be interested in consolidating because they’re not trying to get bigger. They’re fine with having a tiny slice of market share as long as it provides them with enough profit.

SPECIALIZATION IS OFTEN THE KEY TO WINNING INSIDE A FRAGMENTED MARKET, SO DON’T GO OUTSIDE YOUR COMPETENCIES. THE MORE SPECIALIZED YOU ARE, THE MORE BUSINESS YOU CAN WIN.

Expansion in a Fragmented Market

Despite these snags, leaders of services firms within fragmented markets can bypass the typical playbook and grow and scale their businesses by applying alternative methods to get ahead.

The first is through tightly managed decentralization. A firm that’s in the process of consolidating can scale efficiently if its people embrace localization. For example, a notable executive coaching organization has scaled nicely by leveraging the franchising model. This organization creates intellectual capital centrally. Then, the firm licenses the use of its intellectual capital to a network of independent business coaches. Each coach adjusts this toolkit based on the localized market’s unique needs.

The second way to win in a fragmented industry is through geographic expansion backed by a framework of formulas that have worked at previous locations. Another executive coaching organization has been doing this for more than 60 years. It opens new groups by recruiting a geographically focused coach, certifying the coach and expecting the coach to follow a standard operating procedure. This enables the organization to maintain a degree of control as it keeps building its presence outward.

Specialization is a third fragmented market strategy. For instance, many service firms in the IT sector specialize in a technology product and add value through customization and implementation. Case in point: print shops that can handle small batch orders can achieve market share. Players that lead with their deep market segmentation experts are the ones most likely to grab more attention and revenue.

Maximizing Chances in a Fragmented Market

Is a fragmented market an opportunity? Absolutely, if you know the top strategic traps to avoid.

    1. Let go of dominance.

Some firms seek dominance when dominance is impossible. Try not to attempt to consolidate a market that cannot be consolidated. Try to understand the underlying structure of the industry that has caused its fragmentation before you try to consolidate it. In most cases, markets are fragmented for a good reason.

    1. Stay within your core competencies.

Specialization is often the key to winning inside a fragmented market, so try not to go outside your competencies. The more specialized you are, the more business you can win. And inside of a fragmented market, there are plenty of clients to pursue. Try to avoid the temptation of going after clients outside of your core market.

    1. Be cautious of over-centralization.

As firms try to scale, they can often over-centralize. Try not to make this mistake. Consider pushing authority to those closest to the clients to enable and embrace localization and creativity. Remember: the market is fragmented because of the clients. Try to lean into this. Consider developing relationships and be easy to do business with.

    1. Be thankful there are many competitors in your space.

Competition means there are lots of clients spending money on what you do. Therefore, try not to  overreact to your competitors. Their presence is a good thing – and something to be thankful for because it shows a demand for what you offer.

Fragmented markets may be challenging to navigate. However, if you understand how they work, you can gain some serious advantages for your professional services firm.

Photo: Getty Images